Simon Cowell would not be pleased, that’s for sure. American Idol in its 12th season is again making headlines, but this time, it’s not really the ones that they want. Fox’s huge hit is being hit with criticism that the judges are too nice!
Judges Jennifer Lopez, Randy Jackson, and Steven Tyler are being blasted as being to soft on the contestants and doing a lot of back patting and not giving a lot of real feedback. Even Randy Jackson agrees. “I must say Ryan” he said after the judging if the top 13 guys, “we were a little too lenient on some of the boys.”

Idol Judges
The judges, who are all nice people and who are experts at the top of their fields, are all being basically, just too nice. The show is in danger of becoming like so many other reality shows are predictable, overly contrived, and predictable. The word on the street is that the show could possibly go into a tailspin.
The judges seem to have all taken this laid back philosophy of sitting back, watching the contestants sing, and then heaping on an over the top review, where Jennifer Lopez talks about the “goosies” that the contestants gave her and Randy Jackson then calls them “dog” and if anything tells them that maybe it wasn’t their best performance, but it was all right.
Steven Tyler appears to be almost asleep until someone mentions a girl in a short skirt.Hopefully the show will get back where it started. Maybe not the harsh and sometimes downright mean comments of Simon Cowell but something. It would really be of benefit to the contestants. If they are wavering one week and need some help and direction, it would be nice to have someone who knows what their talking about, like any one of the three judges, to help them out.







